I’ve long been a fan of Chuck Palahniuk and his books. He’s written a few of my favorites, including Choke, Lullaby, and Fugitives and Monsters (though I love the entire series of those travel books). I’ve found his work to be engaging and fresh. It always comes from a different place and challenges me as a reader. His latest book Snuff, however falls short.
Snuff focuses on five key figures at a gangbang shoot for a porno: three of the participants, the talent wrangler, and the star going for the world record. We get the perspectives of the participants and the wrangler, alluding to the star. Throughout the book we learn that she mothered a porn-baby and later learn that one of the participants waiting to go on-stage may be that child.
My problem with the book is not the subject matter, but that the plot of the book isn’t enough to keep it going for nearly 200 pages. While the book is full of disturbing/odd/interesting trivia (that may or may not be true), that seems to be the main device (and nothing new for the author). The coy and clever porn movie titles are wildly interesting, but in the end the plot and characters just don’t seem to hold up.
The twist in this book (don’t worry no spoilers ahead), isn’t overly surprising and I guessed it about half way through. Additionally, there isn’t enough tension between, or substance within the characters to make me care about any of them. In the end, I’m left with a very vivid book that doesn’t really go anywhere. Snuff leaves you with a sticky feeling, like you just spent a few hours of your life eating off the craft services table in a basement with a bunch of sweaty, doughy men waiting for sloppy seconds.
Overall I wonder if he’s getting the same love and attention from his editors and publisher as he used to. I haven’t yet read Rant, but based on Snuff and Haunted it seems like he’s being pushed to just release a book a year. It’s interesting that Snuff came out in May of 2008 and his next book PYGMY comes out in May of 2009. However, to be fair, the description of PYGMY sounds interesting and like he’s decided to move in a new direction as a writer.